Netizen 24 IRL: Motorists escaping justice due to summonses not being sent

Motorists escaping justice due to summonses not being sent Significant numbers of motorists who have committed road traffic offences, includ...

Motorists escaping justice due to summonses not being sent

Significant numbers of motorists who have committed road traffic offences, including drink-driving, are escaping the legal system because summonses are not being sent to them, a Garda audit has found.

Garda Commissioner Nóirín O’Sullivan and Minister for Justice Charlie Flanagan are now likely to come under pressure to quantify the “ongoing” problem and also to rectify it.

The offenders in question are not paying fines when a fixed charge notice is initially sent to them. And because the individual gardaí dealing with the cases do not realise they need to then intervene and arrange for a summonses to be sent, the offenders are evading the legal system.

Instead, the prosecuting gardaí erroneously believe a summons will be automatically generated if the fine goes unpaid. The problem is ongoing and the Garda has been unable to determine how many offenders have sidestepped penalty points, fines and the courts in this way.

It means that as well as the near-15,000 motorists having been wrongly convicted because summonses were sent to them in error, significant numbers of motorists who should have received summonses never got them and escaped justice.

The finding is contained in a report by Assistant Commissioner Michael O’Sullivan into the fixed charge processing system published last evening.

Pursuit

A Garda audit of 63 sample cases, which started last September, found that by December a manual summons had been applied for in only 22. In the remaining 41 cases, no summons had been applied for, which meant the offender did not pay their fine and the legal pursuit of them ended.

“The sample examination showed that some of these offences became statute barred,” Mr O’Sullivan’s report states.

Informed Garda sources said all penalty points cases requiring the issuing of a summons would become statute barred within six months.

The report does not set out the full range of offences for which a manual summons must be applied if the initial fine goes unpaid.

Informed Garda sources said drink-driving offences on the lower end of the spectrum â€" which attract penalty points, rather than a driving ban â€" are among those requiring manual summonses if a fine is unpaid.

It was not clear from Mr O’Sullivan’s report why some offences require a manual summons and others involve a summonses being automatically generated by a computer when a fine is unpaid.

The report suggests that in relation to at least some offences “complexities in the summons wording” prevent the summons from being automatically generated.

Confusion

Mr O’Sullivan’s report says that a document called a “manual summons report” is compiled monthly. It is sent to local Garda management in divisions around the State. It is intended to inform them about the cases where the fixed charge notice fine has not been paid and where a manual summons needs to be applied for by the individual garda prosecuting the case.

However, Mr O’Sullivan concludes the manual summons report “remains largely unknown . . . and there still is much confusion about same”.

“An examination by the Garda Roads Polic ing Bureau indicates that the report is not being accessed or used in some cases,” he adds. “And there are cases where an application for a summons by manual intervention has not taken place.

“It appears a large number of these manual summonses were not acted upon by the prosecuting member...The manual summons report was not being accessed by the district offices and therefore was not being forwarded to the relevant members for their attention...This remains an ongoing issue...”

Mr O’Sullivan notes that while the need to access to act on the manual summons report was set out in a directive sent out to Garda members by Garda headquarters in 2014, it is dealt with in a series of mentions in the middle of the 60-page directive.

'; jq(parent).html(htmlBlock); // Hide notification jq(parent).delay( 1000 ).fadeOut( 'slow' ); }); jq(document).on('click', '.read-next--dismiss', function () { // Hide notification jq(this).trigger('notify-hide'); }); jq(document).on('click', '.read-next--more', function() { // show the more info jq('.notifyjs-readNext-base').toggleClass('flipped') }); jq(document).on('click', '.read-next__button--ok', function() { // hide the more info jq('.notifyjs-readNext-base').toggleClass('flipped') }); jq(document).on('click', '.read-next--close', function() { // Hide notification jq(this).trigger('notify-hide'); }); var readNextOptions = { style: "readNext", globalPosition: 'bottom right', clickToHide: false, autoHide: false //autoHideDelay: 8000 }; /* Recommended article */ var articlelink = "https://www.irishtimes.com/news/world/europe/macron-s-messages-fall-on-deaf-ears-as-french-hostilit y-grows-1.3211942"; var articleheadline = "Macron’s messages fall on deaf ears as French hostility grows"; var articleimage = ''; var section = "news"; var evtCategory = "Read Next"; var evtLabel = "https://www.irishtimes.com/news/world/europe/macron-s-messages-fall-on-deaf-ears-as-french-hostility-grows-1.3211942 on https://www.irishtimes.com/news/crime-and-law/motorists-escaping-justice-due-to-summonses-not-being-sent-1.3211961, Back up"; jq.notify.addStyle('readNext', { html: "" + "" + "" + " Suggested for you " + "&q uot; + "" + "" + "" + "" + "" + ""+ "" + "Why am I seeing this?"+ "We suggest this article for you based on what others who have read this article have also read"+ " Ok got it! "+ " Don't show me these again " + "" + "" + "" }); var $context = jq(this); var creCookie = jq.cookie(cookieName) || false; if (creCookie) { jq(this).trigger('notify-hide'); }else{ /* Use smartscroll listener to fire the panel at end of article */ jq(window).smartscroll(function () { //Calculate how far down the page the user has scrolled var scrollPos = (jq(window).scrollTop() / jq('div.article_bodycopy').height()) * 100; scrollPos = Math.round(scrollPos); if (scrollPos > 75) { showContent++; if (showContent == 1) { jq.notify({ headline: articleheadline, image: articleimage }, readNextOptions); if (currentWindowWidth && currentWindowWidthSource: Google News

COMMENTS

Nama

Accessory,1,Apartment,1,Application,1,Automotive,3,Bank,1,Beauty,2,Board,1,Breakfast,2,Budget Living,1,Building,1,Business,2,Car Accessory,2,Car part,1,Car Shop,1,Celebrity,4,Cloth accessory,1,Cooking,1,Cover,2,Deals,1,Design,3,Digital Life,1,Dinner,1,Dish Review,2,DIY Projects,3,Economy,2,Education,2,Engine,1,Entertainment,1,Expert Advices,2,Fashion,2,Financial,1,Food,3,Football,1,Games,1,Gossip,1,Heath,1,Hotels,1,House,2,Individual,1,Inspiration,2,Latin,1,Lifestyle,6,Live Show,1,Love,1,Lunch,2,Model,1,Music,2,Nutrition,1,Olympic,1,Politics,1,Pop Shop,1,Rock,1,Sports,1,Startup,1,Stock,1,Tech Review,1,Tech Tips,1,Technology,2,Tennis,1,Tone Set,1,Travel,1,Trip Ideas,1,Vogue,1,Weather,1,Wedding,1,World,3,
ltr
item
Netizen 24 Ireland: Netizen 24 IRL: Motorists escaping justice due to summonses not being sent
Netizen 24 IRL: Motorists escaping justice due to summonses not being sent
https://www.irishtimes.com/news/crime-and-law/"'
Netizen 24 Ireland
http://www.ireland.netizen24.com/2017/09/netizen-24-irl-motorists-escaping.html
http://www.ireland.netizen24.com/
http://www.ireland.netizen24.com/
http://www.ireland.netizen24.com/2017/09/netizen-24-irl-motorists-escaping.html
true
3730684180205554463
UTF-8
Loaded All Posts Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS CONTENT IS PREMIUM Please share to unlock Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy