Netizen 24 IRL: Judge directs that woman who brought €60k fake damages case be reported to gardai

Judge directs that woman who brought €60k fake damages case be reported to gardai Judge directs that woman who brought €60k fake damages...

Judge directs that woman who brought €60k fake damages case be reported to gardai

Judge directs that woman who brought €60k fake damages case be reported to gardai
Stock picture
Stock picture

Ray Managh

The President of the Circuit Court has directed the legal team of a leading insurance company to provide papers in a fraudulent €60,000 damages claim to the Garda for investigation.

Mr Justice Raymond Groarke described Angela McDonagh as “a fraud” who had deliberately set a trap for an unsuspecting driver behind her by slamming on her brakes and causing a rear-ending accident.

“The plaintiff is a fraud who has brought a fraudulent claim set up in an amateur fashion by the slamming on of her brakes,” Judge Groarke said.

Barrister Mark Dunne, counsel for Aviva Insurance, told the Circuit Civil Court that the company’s insured driver Catherine O’Sullivan, of Coolock, Dublin, had been unable to avoid a collision when Ms McDonagh, for no reason, had slammed on her brakes as she approached a roundabout.

McDonagh, (28) of Brookthorpe, Gloucester, England, denied when cross-examined by Mr Dunne that two days after the January 31, 2015 accident at Swords, Co Dublin, she had been involved in an accident in Monaghan on February 2 despite having claimed she was in Gloustershire on that day.

After she denied involvement in the Monaghan accident Mr Dunne called Garda Diarmuid Leane, Monaghan, who said he had taken Ms McDonagh's name and address at the scene of the Monaghan collision and he recognised that woman as the woman in court bringing the claim arising out of the Swords collision two days earlier.

G arda Leane said Ms McDonagh had given her address as Newport, South Wales, the same address she had given to Ms O’Sullivan in the Co Dublin collision.

Mr Dunne questioned McDonagh about an alleged slip she had in Tesco’s in Ireland in May 2013 and referred to evidence that she had actually slipped the day before in England where she had a surgical slab fitted to her wrist. Ms McDonagh said she had slipped in both countries on consecutive days but only had a bandage on her arm when the second slip had occurred.

Judge Groarke said the defendant had claimed in its defence that Ms McDonagh had set up the motor accident to entrap Ms O’Sullivan and he had to balance the credibility of Ms McDonagh’s evidence as against the credibility of Ms O’Sullivan.

He said Ms McDonagh had not called any of her passengers to back up her claim about the Swords accident and he found the evidence of Ms O’Sullivan to the effect that the brakes had been slammed on for no r eason to be compelling and reliable.

He dismissed Ms McDonagh’s claim with costs against her and directed the matter be reported to the Garda.

Rob Smyth, head of Aviva’s anti-fraud section, said after the case that the court’s decision vindicated Aviva’s decision to defend all spurious claims as part of the company’s zero tolerance strategy.

Online Editors

Follow @Independent_ie

Promoted Links

Nauris Zeps, of Phibblestown House, Clonsilla, Dublin 15 pictured leaving the Four Courts Pic: Collins Courts

Stripper (32) who claimed he couldn't lift children due to crash loses case after...

Laura Lynott A man who could have been awarded up to €40,000 for whiplash, claiming he couldn't lift his children after a car crash, had his case thrown out after a court watched footage of him performing on...

Max Schrems leaves the High Court in Dublin.

Privacy campaigner entitled to sue Facebook Ireland through Austrian court

Siobhan Fenton The Advocate General in Europe's highest court has said a privacy campaigner is entitled to sue Facebook Ireland through the Austrian courts.

Dayna Kearney arrives at Naas Circuit Criminal Court at an earlier hearing. Photo: Collins

Young woman charged with dangerous driving involving the death of her four friends has...

Alan O'Keeffe A woman charged with dangerous driving involving the death of her four friends had her case adjourned today until January 30.

  • Most Read
  • Most Shared
Garda Amanda Lynch (37), who was savagely beaten in the line of duty, leaving court yesterday. Photo: Collins Courts

Gangland murder victim was part of gang who viciously attacked female garda Courts

Garda Amanda Lynch    (37), who was savagely beaten in the line of duty, leaving court yesterday. Photo: Collins Courts

Garda who suffered vicious gang attack is awarded €105,000 Courts

Regina McNern

Arrest warrant issued for woman who made false rape claim Courts

Dayna Kearney arrives at Naas Circuit Criminal Court at an earlier hearing. Photo: Collins

Young woman charged with dangerous driving involving the death of her four... Courts

'We had just 42 hours with Laoise' - parents whose baby girl died after heart pierced during... Courts

WATCH: Hilarious moment Irish rally drivers crash and have the most Irish reaction Sport Video

Year-on-year chnage compared with Q3 2016

Revealed: The average rent in each county in Ireland Property & Mortgages

Research by Japanese scientists has found that people who eat slowly are less likely to gain weight. Stock Image: Getty Images/EyeEm

Heart risks higher for fast eaters Healthy Eating

Mr Pat Carton. Image via Garrett FitzGerald Photography

"I operated on 15-year old inter-county minor who had both hips done' - Top... Health & Wellbeing

Stock photo

House prices to rise 20pc over the next three years but 'market is not Property & Mortgages

Independent.ie

The Daily Digest

Promoted Links

Editor's Choice

A scrutiny of the GPA finances for last year makes for interesting reading. Photo: Cody Glenn

Colm O'Rourke: What really intrigued me from the GPA financial report was the wage bill

At this time of year...

A portrait picture of McClean taken by David Maher. Photo: Sportsfile

James McClean uncovered - Dani el McDonnell shines a light on the man behind the headlines

This is...

Last month, TV presenter Holly Willoughby (36) dressed up as a unicorn for a special Halloween edition of ITV's This Morning.

Generation Juvenile: glittering accessories, colouring books and unicorns - are some too scared to grow...

Secretary General of the Department of Justice & Equality Noel Waters Picture: Tom Burke

Breaking More change in the Justice Department as garda questions are raised in the Dáil

The Justice Department’s most senior official, Noel...

Nauris Zeps, of Phibblestown House, Clonsilla, Dublin 15 pictured leaving the Four Courts Pic: Collins Courts

Stripper (32) who claimed he couldn't lift children due to crash loses case after...

A man who could have been awarded up to €40,000...

Stock picture

Judge directs that woman who brought €60k fake damages case be reported to gardai

The President of the Circuit Court has directed the legal...

Max Schrems leaves the High Court in Dublin.

Privacy campaigner entitled to sue Facebook Ireland through Austrian court

The Advocate General in Europe's highest court has said a...

Gary Haggarty. Photo: Sunday World

Supergrass to be used as witness in prosecution of man over 1994 murder of two...

One man is to be prosecuted using evidence from a...

Dayna Kearney arrives at Naas Circuit Criminal Court at an earlier hearing. Photo: Collins

Young woman charged with dangerous driving involving the death of her four...

A woman charged with dangerous driving involving the...

Hiqa (stock image)

Inspectors find 14 incidents of 'potential abuse' at Dublin disability centre

Inspectors found 14 incidents of potential abuse at...

Gardai are appealing for witnesses after two elderly women were mugged in south Dublin on the same night.

Elderly woman (83) mugged in south Dublin 'had just €3 in her bag'

Gardai are appealing for witnesses after two elderly...

Do you find the default 9-5 workday schedule too rigid?

#HaveYourSay: What is your ideal workday shift?

The typical workday is around eight hours but what if you had a level of flexibility...

The Luas . Photo: Caroline Quinn

Longer Luas trams to be introduced on the Green Line

Longer Luas trams are on the way in a bid to ease congestion in the capital,...

Laoise Ni Scolai's parents Irene Kavanagh and Coilin O’Scolai at the inquest today

VIDEO: 'We have been left shattered' - parents of newborn who died after...

A coroner has returned a verdict of medical...

WATCH: Driver uses hard shoulder to undertake lorry on busy airport road

This is the moment a driver used the hard...

VIDEO: 'I don't w ant to be on the same list as a killer... a pariah' - Bob Geldof...

Bob Geldof said he regrets having to hand back...

WATCH: Meet Ireland’s first prototype robot for assisted care

The prototype robot has been designed to...

VIDEO: New measures announced to tackle sexual harassments in arts sector

New measures announced to tackle sexual...

VIDEO: Sinn Féin councillor resigns over bullying claims

One of Sinn Féin's most high-profile councillors has quit the party amid clai ms he and...

VIDEO: Airliner makes emergency landing in Belfast with no nose gear

A Flybe aircraft has been forced to carry out...

WATCH: Cathedral opens up service for pets

Officials at St Anne's Cathedral in Belfast may have been inspired by The Vicar of...

WATCH: Would you give Facebook your nudes?

Members of the Irish public were divided today about whether they would trust...

WATCH: Would you use gender neutral changing rooms?

Topshop and Topman are one of the first high street stores in Ireland to...

Picture: Ganly Walters Estate Agents

In pictures: No 3 Howth Court

Tina Maguire:

In Pictures: Ireland's best Halloween costumes

Our readers shared their Halloween costumes and the results were a...

Runners at the 2017 Dublin Marathon (Photo: Steve Humphreys)

See anyone you know?! This year's Dublin Marathon is another massive success

Hurricane 'Ophelia'.... fallen trees Marina Park, Cork City Pic Michael Mac Sweeney/Provision

In Pictures: Storm Ophelia damage in Cork

Hurricane Ophelia hits the coast of Mayo today Photo: Paul Mealey

Ten shocking images that show the true devastation of Storm Ophelia

A man and his dog walk past a fallen tree in the Killarney Demesne after Hurricane Ophelia on Monday. Photo Don MacMonagle

In Pictures: 16 of the most dramatic shots as Storm Ophelia hits Ireland

As Hurricane Ophelia continues in Galway people taking video of themselves out in the Height of the storm at the Spanish arch and Claddgh area of Galway . Photo:Andrew Downes

In Pictures: Hurricane Ophelia takes hold of Ireland

Ray MacSharry, Minister for Finance, holds aloft the Budget Bag.

In pictures: Budget day down through the years

Demonstrators let off flares during a march for more liberal Irish abortion laws, in Dublin, Ireland September 30, 2017. REUTERS/Clodagh Kilcoyne

In Pictures: Thousands take to the streets of Dublin for pro-choice rally

Thousands of pro-choice campaigners took to...

17/9/17 Fans Finn Curtis, age 8 and Max Young, age 8, Crumlin celebrating Dublin's third time in a row winning the All Ireland final against Mayo. Picture: Arthur Carron

In pictures: Smithfield plaza turns blue as fans turn out to celebrate three in a row

Source: Google News

COMMENTS

Nama

Accessory,1,Apartment,1,Application,1,Automotive,3,Bank,1,Beauty,2,Board,1,Breakfast,2,Budget Living,1,Building,1,Business,2,Car Accessory,2,Car part,1,Car Shop,1,Celebrity,4,Cloth accessory,1,Cooking,1,Cover,2,Deals,1,Design,3,Digital Life,1,Dinner,1,Dish Review,2,DIY Projects,3,Economy,2,Education,2,Engine,1,Entertainment,1,Expert Advices,2,Fashion,2,Financial,1,Food,3,Football,1,Games,1,Gossip,1,Heath,1,Hotels,1,House,2,Individual,1,Inspiration,2,Latin,1,Lifestyle,6,Live Show,1,Love,1,Lunch,2,Model,1,Music,2,Nutrition,1,Olympic,1,Politics,1,Pop Shop,1,Rock,1,Sports,1,Startup,1,Stock,1,Tech Review,1,Tech Tips,1,Technology,2,Tennis,1,Tone Set,1,Travel,1,Trip Ideas,1,Vogue,1,Weather,1,Wedding,1,World,3,
ltr
item
Netizen 24 Ireland: Netizen 24 IRL: Judge directs that woman who brought €60k fake damages case be reported to gardai
Netizen 24 IRL: Judge directs that woman who brought €60k fake damages case be reported to gardai
https://cdn-01.independent.ie/incoming/article34173292.ece/20ef9/AUTOCROP/h342/hammer%20and%20gavel
Netizen 24 Ireland
http://www.ireland.netizen24.com/2017/11/netizen-24-irl-judge-directs-that-woman.html
http://www.ireland.netizen24.com/
http://www.ireland.netizen24.com/
http://www.ireland.netizen24.com/2017/11/netizen-24-irl-judge-directs-that-woman.html
true
3730684180205554463
UTF-8
Loaded All Posts Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS CONTENT IS PREMIUM Please share to unlock Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy