Netizen 24 IRL: Cork man's murder conviction quashed over jury visit and experiment at scene

Diposting oleh On 12.51

Cork man's murder conviction quashed over jury visit and experiment at scene

Cork man's murder conviction quashed over jury visit and experiment at scene

David O’Loughlin was found guilty of murdering a man he assaulted and forced into the refuse chute of an apartment building in 2013

David O’Loughlin
David O’Loughlin

Ruaidhri Giblin

A Cork man found guilty of murdering a man he assaulted and forced into the refuse chute of an apartment building, where he got snagged and died, has had his conviction quashed over the jury's visit to the scene.

David O’Loughlin (30), of Garden City Apartments, North Main Street, Cork, had pleaded not guilty to the murder of Liam Manley (59) at his apartment complex in the city on May 12th 2013.

A Central Criminal Court jury sitting in Cork unanimously found O'Loughlin guilty of murder and he was accordingly given the mandatory life sentence by Mr Justice Paul Carney on March 31, 2015.

The Court of Appeal heard that after some considerable time deliberating, the foreman of the jury asked for permission to visit the chute before making a final decision. It's not common for a jury to visit a location but it's by no means unheard of. It was not known to have happened during jury deliberations before, which is what happened in this case.

Quashing the verdict today, Mr Justice Alan Mahon said the decision to permit the jury's visit to the chute in the absence of an application from either the defence or the prosecution was technically unlawful and in conflict with section 22 of the Juries Act.

While examining the scene, at least one juror conducted a form of ex periment by throwing a stone down the chute - apparently done with the knowledge of the trial judge but in the absence of either the prosecution or defence.

Mr Justice Mahon said it was unclear what information the jury expected to learn from the experiment but the throwing of the stone put the visit to the chute on an “entirely different level”.

Counsel for O'Loughlin, Michael O'Higgins SC, said there was simply no way of knowing if one juror had a concern, which wasn't a real concern, or whether somebody was getting into the physics of it which in effect introduced new evidence into the case. He said the reason and result of the experiment was unknown and unexplained.

Mr Justice Mahon, who sat with Mr Justice George Birmingham and Mr Justice John Hedigan, said the jury ought to have been discharged in the particular circumstances in which these events occurred.

The three-judge court will hear submissions on whether or not to order a retrial at a later date.

Giving background, Mr Justice Mahon said O'Loughlin found the deceased sitting on the pavement outside a shop in Cork City where he lived. He felt sorry for the deceased because he himself had previously fallen on hard times, and took him back to his apartment.

Shortly afterwards a friend of O'Loughlin called to his apartment. Both he and the deceased had previously stayed with the Simon Community in Cork.

Something triggered O'Loughlin who then assaulted the deceased. He ejected him from his apartment and forcibly pushed him into a rubbish chute which was used to take bags of rubbish from various apartments floors down to the basement area.

O'Loughlin maintained that he did not in any way intend to harm the deceased and he assumed he would simply have slid safely down into the basement area and then leave the building.

However, there was a slight bend in the chute which caused refuse bag s to occasionally jam and block the chute.

The following morning, a maintenance man attempted to unblock the chute and as he did so, the deceased's body released itself and dropped down.

Dr Margot Bolster, the Assistant State Pathologist, gave evidence that the cause of death was mechanical asphyxia, associated positional asphyxia and hypoxia or lack of oxygen due to being trapped inside the chute.

Mr Manley had been homeless for some period of time and had lived in homeless accommodation in the city. He had a problem with alcohol and on the night in question, had been turned away from a hostel facility because he was intoxicated, and told to return later when he sobered up.

O'Loughlin gave evidence and emphasised that he never wished to harm or kill Mr Manley and that he was devastated as a consequence of what occurred. He said he honestly believed the deceased would simply slide down and exit into a bin of rubbish below which would break his fall, and that he would not have been injured, let alone die.

During the trial, the jury had seen photographs of the chute and had heard expert evidence as to the speed at which Mr Manley would have travelled through and exited the chute had his passage not become blocked by rubbish bags.

After some considerable time deliberating, and after they were given the option of returning a majority verdict, the foreman of the jury asked for an opportunity to visit the chute before making a final decision.

While the jury were examining the scene, at least one member of the jury was permitted to throw a stone down the chute. This was done in the absence of O'Loughlin or his legal representatives.

By the time O'Loughlin and his lawyers arrived to the apartment building, they found the trial judge getting into a lift to exit the building. O'Loughlin had been represented by the late Brendan Nix SC for his trial.

No one was present on behalf of the prosecution, they having apparently visited the scene earlier.

Mr O'Higgins said the whole process took place in the absence of both parties. “It ought not to have happened to begin with”, ought not to have happened in the absence of both parties and the “experiment” with the stone ought not to have happened, counsel submitted.

Was it to satisfy some off-beat question a single juror had or had the jury formed a view of something that might have involved force or speed or physics, counsel asked.

There was simply no way of knowing if it was one juror with a concern, which wasn't a real concern, or whether somebody was getting into the physics of it which in effect introduced new evidence into the case, counsel submitted.

Online Editors

Follow @Independent_ie

Promoted Links

Model and aspiring actor who appeared on Love/Hate jailed for possession of...

Declan Brennan A man with previous convictions for drug dealing has been jailed after he was caught with hundreds of ecstasy tablets.

The last picture taken of Warren O'Connor

Breaking Man extradited to appear in court charged with 2010 murder of Warren O'Connor

Ken Foy A man in his 30s has been arrested in connection to the death of soldier Warren O'Connor eight years ago.

Adam Nolan

Teenager (19) charged with murder of man (52) in Dublin

Tom Tuite A 19-YEAR-OLD youth has been remanded in custody after he was charged with the murder of a man who died following a stabbing at his partner’s home in west Dublin.

  • Most Read
  • Most Shared
Leonard Nolan (53), a fast food delivery man, of Pearse Gardens, Sallynoggin, Dublin pictured leaving the Four Courts after a High Court action Pic: Collins Courts

Delivery driver sues south Dublin pub for defamation after barman said €10 note was fake,... Courts

Paddy Jackson arrives at Belfast Crown Court. Photo: PA

Jury in rugby rape trial visit home of Paddy Jackson where alleged crimes took place Courts

John Doherty (55) of Patrician Villas, Stillorgan, Co Dublin pleaded guilty to two counts of sexually assaulting his step-daughter on dates between January 1996 and April 1998 at their home in Stillorgan, when she was aged 12 and 13 Pic Collins Courts

'I loved him and trusted him unconditionally and he betrayed me' - Man (55) who... Courts

David O’Loughlin

Cork man's murder conviction quashed over jury visit and experiment at scene Courts

ON TRIAL: From left to right, Ireland and Ulster player Paddy Jackson, 26, his team-mate Stuart Olding, 24, and third defendant Blane McIlroy, 26, arrive at Belfast Crown Court last week

'I was not staring at Paddy Jackson,' insists accuser Courts

Black Panther

Black Panther first review: 'It is expected to stand for something bigger than... Movie Reviews

A 15-bedroom period house at Boyle

10 country mansions for less than the price of a Dublin city apartment Homes

Dr Ali Selim Photo: RTE

Female circumcision 'should be allowed by law' - leading member of Ireland's Islamic... Irish News

Leonard Nolan (53), a fast food delivery man, of Pearse Gardens, Sallynoggin, Dublin pictured leaving the Four Courts after a High Court action Pic: Collins Courts

Delivery driver sues south Dublin pu b for defamation after barman said €10 note was fake,... Courts

Lisselan House comes with 315ac, 205ac of which is in tillage and grazing ground

In Pictures: Black pudding millionaire snaps up Cork mansion on 300 acres and its... Results

Independent.ie

The Daily Digest

Promoted Links

Editor's Choice

The King’s Hospital rugby players face their supporters ahead of a Leinster Schools Senior Cup match at Donnybrook Stadium. Photo: Cody Glenn/Sportsfile

How the decision to send a child to boarding school is not made lightly

Picture this - you get up at 6:00am,...

Harry Gregg

Haunting guilt of reluctant hero - Read powerful interview with Munich air disaster survivor Harry Gregg...

Emo Court Gardens, Laois

Ireland's 20 best walks: Joe O'Shea's pick of family-friendly trails

The coffin of A   bigael Conlon (3) at her funeral at The Church of Mary Immaculate, Inchicore today

'She was loved and cherished in life' - Hundreds attend funeral of girl (3) killed in...

Hundreds of mourners attended the funeral today of...

Daniel Doyle (30), with an address in Ballymun, north Dublin, appeared before Dublin Circuit Court charged with being in possession of drugs for sale and supply Pic Collins Courts

Model and aspiring actor who appeared on Love/Hate jailed for possession of ecstasy

A man with previous convictions for drug dealing has...

Longstanding Daffodil Volunteer James Gilleran from Navan Road Dublin goes down on bended knee to Miriam O'Callaghan who spoke at the launch of Daffodil Day at CityWest Hotel. Pic Steve Humphreys

Daffodil Day launch hears 40,000 people expected to be diagnosed with cancer this...

MORE than €3 million is needed to help the Irish...

The last picture taken of Warren O'Connor

Breaking Man extradited to appear in court charged with 2010 murder of Warren O'Connor

A man in his 30s has been arrested in connection to the...

Portuguese MMA fighter Joao Carvalho (on right) during his bout with Charlie Ward. Photo: Dave Fogarty

MMA leaders 'dragging their feet' on safety, says minister as inquest recommends...

Mixed Martial Arts (MMA) leaders have come under...

Tina Cahill and David Walsh celebrating their engagement in Australia in a social media picture at the New Year

Wexford woman denies murdering fiancé as police seek witnesses in Ireland...

An Irish woman accused of stabbing her fiancé...

Adam Nolan

Teenager (19) charged with murder of man (52) in Dublin

A 19-YEAR-OLD youth has been remanded in custody after he was charged with the...

Stock image

Mother-of-one who fraudulently claimed over €88k in social welfare...

A woman who fraudulently claimed over €88,000 from the...

Former artistic director of the Gate Theatre Michael Colgan. Photo: Damien Eagers

Independent review at Gate Theatre finds Michael Colgan has 'case to answer' over...

An independent review into allegations of...

Leonard Nolan (53), a fast food delivery man, of Pearse Gardens, Sallynoggin, Dublin pictured leaving the Four Courts after a High Court action Pic: Collins Courts

Delivery driver sues south Dublin pub for defamation after barman said €10 note...

A man says he was defamed when he was told by a...

WATCH Miriam O'Callaghan launches Daffodil day 2018

VIDEO: Checks at Irish border 'unavoidable' after Brexit, warns Barnier

Checks at the Irish border will be "unavoidable"...

VIDEO: Inquest into death of MMA fighter returns death by misadventure verdict

MMA fighter Charlie Ward told of his...

VIDEO: Longer Luas trams could cause more traffic problems in Dublin

VIDEO: Cross examination of woman continues in rape trial

Cross examination of woman continues in rape trial

Scene of the Fatal Stabbing of a 52 year old male on Buirg Na Ri Walk Balgaddy .

VIDEO: Teen (19) held after man (52) killed in stabbing in Dublin

Gardaí are investigating the fatal stabbing of a...

VIDEO: 'Just look at Sean. He did nothing wrong' - Father in plea for driver to hand...

The father of a 14-year-old boy who was left...

The Lovely Ladies Syndicate from Portiuncula Hospital who scooped €500,000 between then in the EuroMillions Plus draw celebrate their win

WATCH: Galway Hospital staff syndicate celebrate as they scoop EuroMillions Plus...

An 18-person syndicate made up of staff at...

VIDEO - School bus crash in Limerick: 24 students and two adults hospitalised

All but four of t he students injured in an early...

WATCH: Dáil suspended after a massive shouting match between th Healy Rae...

The Dáil has been suspended after a massive...

Lisa Gerencser and Agnes Toch, Hungry taking part in The New Years Day Bray Sea Swim at Bray PIC COLIN O'RIORDAN

In Pictures: Hardy people enjoy a New Year's Day swim

Matt Murphy sent this lovely photo of his family who spend each Christmas in Freiburg, Germ   any to take advantage of the weather

In pictures: How the Irish abroad are spending Christmas away from home

Cpl Lily Ray Carlow (111 Inf Bn, UNIFIL) Wishing my girlfriend Celine a very happy Christmas miss you and wishing my family and all the gang from Gallbally and the girls from Kiss a wonderful Christmas Love Lily

In pictures: Irish soldiers stationed abroad send Christmas messages home

Fina Dooley from Mount Merrion greets her Grandchildren Daniel Kelleher 4 & Nicholas Kelleher 2 from London Photo: Gareth Chaney Collins

A festive welcome at Dublin Airport

Kevin 'Boxer' Moran T.D. arrives for the Irish premiere of Star Wars: The Last Jedi. Savoy Cinema, O'Connell Street, Dublin. Picture: Caroline Quinn

Star Wars premiere in Dublin

Bonny a Cavachon King Charles cross cocker spaniel from Cabra during a Carol Service with Peata Therapy Dogs at Chirst church Cathedral , Dublin. Photo: Gareth Chaney Collins

In pictures: A canine carol service

Santa and his Elves, Harry Potter, Trolls, Beauty and the Beast transform Our Lady’s Children’s Hospital, Crumlin into a magical fantasy land on their Annual Ho Ho Day. Pictured is two and a half-year-old Oliver Jalowiecki from Galway pictured with Santa Claus (Gerry Cully) from CMRF and Mrs. Claus (Pauline Robinson) from Our Lady’s Childr   en’s Hospital, Crumlin. PHOTO: Mark Stedman

In pictures: Santa and his elves visit Our Lady's Children's Hospital

Gerard Heneghan took this picture at his home in Clonberne, County Galway of his dog Riley

A Winter Wonderland: Some of the best pictures from around the country as cold snap continues

The most amazing snow pictures so far as freezing blast hits

No. 3 Howth Court. Picture: Ganly Walters Estate Agents

In pictures: No 3 Howth Court

Source: Google News

Next
« Prev Post
Previous
Next Post »